top of page
In a letter to the NJBPU, our Office of Peace, Justice, and Integrity of Creation called for data centers to cover their operating costs along with the protection of our communities and natural resources. Technological progress must reflect our commitment to justice and care for creation.

November 9, 2026
President Ben Hertz-Shargel
New Jersey Board of Public Utilities 44 South Clinton Avenue, 7th Floor Trenton, NJ 08625
Re: Docket EO26080463 — Data Center Fair Share Act
Dear President Hertz-Shargel:
New Jersey’s energy future must serve the common good. Families and small businesses should not subsidize data centers. Effective protection begins with an evidence-based determination of which facilities qualify as “large data centers.”
While current law directs the Board to define “large data centers” using an electricity-demand threshold of 50 megawatts or less, adopting the statutory maximum, the 25-megawatt recommendation proposed by some advocates, or any other figure without supporting evidence constitutes poor policy implementation. The Board should compare suggested thresholds against utility-specific data on requested capacity, existing peak demand figures, the grid’s ability to handle additional loads, capital improvement costs, and the combined needs of related facilities. The Board should publish its analysis and explain how the chosen threshold would protect residents and business owners from cost increases. If thresholds vary by service area, the public deserves a clear explanation of how local electricity demand and grid conditions justify those differences. The established threshold should be reviewed periodically as technology and grid conditions change, recognizing improved efficiency and accounting for costly upgrades and demand increases. Developers must not evade these requirements by subdividing developments into separately owned, individually metered facilities. Utility providers must identify the costs of servicing data centers and explain how shared expenses are allocated, and the Board should prohibit utility providers from passing on infrastructure costs to households and small businesses if developers fail to pay their share of those costs. Furthermore, data centers must honor agreements to reduce electricity use during periods of grid strain, publicly report the size and duration of those reductions, and face strict penalties for noncompliance.
Additionally, the NJBPU should coordinate with the NJDEP and local officials to assess noise pollution from cooling equipment, generators, and related utility infrastructure before a data center becomes operational, accounting for nighttime disturbances and combined noise from nearby facilities. Ongoing monitoring, correction of violations, and a straightforward complaint process offering timely relief are essential to protecting surrounding communities.
Catholic social teaching calls for economic development that serves the common good and prioritizes the disadvantaged members of our community. The Charism of Charity calls us to keep the most vulnerable at the center of policy, from design through implementation to enforcement. I urge the Board to adopt enforceable standards that protect at-risk families, require data centers to pay the costs attributable to their operations, and remain responsive to industry changes.
Very truly yours,
Mr. Joseph N. Pastino, Director Sisters of Charity of Saint Elizabeth | Office of Peace, Justice, and Integrity of Creation
P.O. Box 476 | Convent Station, NJ | 07961-0476

69630332_2288174131310650_86251734629288

La misión de la Oficina de Paz, Justicia e Integridad Ecológica tiene sus raíces en la convicción de las Hermanas de la Caridad de Santa Isabel, “que una vida de caridad requiere una fe que haga justicia” ( Toward Boundless Charity, C20 ). La Oficina proporciona recursos y educación a las Hermanas de la Caridad de Santa Isabel, Asociadas de Seton y otras personas que comparten nuestra pasión en su trabajo de defensa en torno a temas de paz, justicia e integridad ecológica.

Los temas prioritarios actuales de la Oficina de Paz, Justicia e Integridad Ecológica, inspirados en la Doctrina Social Católica e informados por nuestra tradición de espiritualidad vicentino-setoniana, son pobreza, mujeres, migrantes y refugiados, trata de personas, paz y no violencia, racismo y integridad ecológica.

La Oficina de Paz, Justicia e Integridad Ecológica tiene un Director, un Comité Asesor de Hermanas y Asociados de Seton, y comités dedicados a temas específicos.                                                                                                                        

The Sisters of Charity of Saint Elizabeth made their voices heard at the "No Kings" Protest in Morristown, NJ, joining thousands in a call for justice and peace. On June 14, 2025, Sisters, Associates, and staff from Convent Station marched with purpose; banners high, spirits higher, and bold shirts reading:

 

“Working for Peace, Justice, Earth.”As Sister Marion Scranton, SC, told NorthJersey.com:

 

“We always are on the side of the poor, looking for justice and peace in this fractured world."

 

Read more about their presence and message in the full article from NorthJersey.com 

Pictured: Sister Dianne Moore, SC

Hermanas de la Caridad de Santa Isabel Paz, justicia e integridad ecológica - Temas prioritarios

(Haga clic en los iconos a continuación para obtener más información)

The Commitment of the Sisters of Charity of Saint Elizabeth to People Experiencing Homelessness

The Sisters of Charity of Saint Elizabeth, convened in their 2019 General Assembly, prayerfully reflected on the persistent and widespread nature of homelessness experienced by persons locally, across our nation and around the globe. We were challenged to take actions which highlight this crisis, to commit ourselves to being informed and educated about the causes, to collaborate in advocacy efforts with other groups and organizations and to address this issue with public officials at all levels of government.

Click each Icon for further information

HERMANAS DE LA CARIDAD DE SAN ELIZABETH

COMITÉ DE PAZ, JUSTICIA E INTEGRIDAD ECOLÓGICA

                                                                                                                                      

Padre Terrence Moran (Director, Oficina del PJEI)

Hermana Jacquelyn Balasia, SC

Hermana Mary Canavan, SC

Hermana Roberta Feil, SC

Gerard Gannon

Mary Gannon (asociada de Seton)

Hermana Ellen Farrell, SC (Enlace del consejo)

Hermana Marie Goetschalckx, Carolina del Sur, Seton Hill

Hermana Elizabeth Kremp, SC

Hermana Janet McLaughlin, SC

Hermana Patricia Mennor, SC

Hermana Marie Russo, SC

Hermana Mary Spano, SC

Hermana Margaret Welch, SC

Sisters of Charity of Saint Elizabeth NE

Hermanas de la Caridad de Santa Isabel | PO BOX 476 | Convent Station, Nueva Jersey 07961-0476

973-290-5000 | escharity@scnj.org

30-301979_logo-for-website-linkedin-logo-vector-free-download.png
  • Instagram
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • YouTube
bottom of page